Investment Magazine
 

The zero sum game of active asset management

  • 27 February, 2012
  • 0
  • print
This is an archived article originally published on I&T News
“It doesn’t mean no one can beat the market but someone has to lose,” says Wilson Sy

Active asset managers are hired by the $1.3 trillion superannuation fund industry so they can differentiate themselves from each other, says Wilson Sy, a visiting fellow at the University of Western Australia who was a senior advisor to the Super System Review.

Sy says the debate on whether active or passive asset management is a long-running saga that has yet to be resolved.

He says a large enough sample of active managers will show their returns are zero or negative relative to the index. The average asset weighted returns of all investors must equal the market capitalisation return, says Sy.

“It doesn’t mean no one can beat the market but someone has to lose,” he says. “The losers either don’t know they’re losing or the institutional investor keeps giving them money.”

Sy spoke on the sidelines of an asset management workshop organised by Ron Bird at the University of Technology’s Paul Woolley Centre for the Study of Capital Market Dysfunctionality.

© Copyright: Whole articles from this website and newsletter cannot be reproduced without permission from the editor. If you wish to publish introductions to any article please ensure that it links to original content site www.investmentmagazine.com.au, and that it shows clear attribution to Investment Magazine, plus author name and date. Failure to abide by this request will be considered a breach of copyright and legal action will be taken.

Vote
Is core property and global infrastructure heading for a price bubble?
 
in News

QSuper segregates pension assets

QSuper has segregated $10 billion in assets held for members in retirement to capitalise on greater tax efficiencies. The change is expected to ... [more]

What is your fund doing about this graph?

Over 13 years of writing about pensions the graph below is one I have barely seen, but over the last few weeks it ... [more]

in News

Cbus wants impact study of pension at age 70

Cbus is to undertake an examination into the potential impacts on its members of shifting the pension age to 70. The fund has ... [more]

in News

Door opens onto full Chinese equity market

The diversity of Chinese equity portfolios is to increase when the number of companies accessible to foreign investors doubles at the end of ... [more]

in News

The great post-retirement opportunity

Australia has the opportunity to lead the world in post-retirement products and export its know-how, according to Moshe Milevsky, the internationally renowned author ... [more]

in News

Super Fund Awards’ finalists announced

The finalists of the Chant West/Conexus Financial Super Fund Awards have been announced by the research house Chant West. The fund ratings firm ... [more]

in News

New Vision Super CIO to target investment costs

Michael Wrysch has been tasked with reducing Vision Super’s investment costs as part of his new role as chief investment officer of the ... [more]

NGS rebrand – ‘for those who understand the true meaning of wealth’

A week after trustees of industry funds were warned that without a brand strategy they would not survive the ‘medium term’, NGS Super ... [more]

in News

Sunsuper confronts lack of board diversity

Sunsuper has improved the gender and geographical diversity of its board with the appointment of the Sydney based Elizabeth Hallett as an employer ... [more]

in News

QSuper’s cohort strategies pose challenge to US and UK schemes

QSuper’s creation of eight different investment cohorts for its members has sparked curiosity and admiration from defined contribution experts in the US and ... [more]

in News

CBUS members welcome income projections

CBUS has gained a 97 per cent approval rate from members for statements which confront them with an estimate of their income in ... [more]

in News

Sunsuper: a growing provider of private capital

Sunsuper is expanding its investment team to help it take greater advantage of investment opportunities. The fund, which runs $28 billion in assets, ... [more]

in News

Cost of Stronger Super leads to Media Super cutting CIO role

The cost of Stronger Super compliance and product development has led Media Super to cut the role of chief investment officer. Jon Glass ... [more]

in News

Sunsuper expands investment team to 18

Sunsuper has increased the size of its investment team to 18 with the appointment of Lounarda David to the newly created role of ... [more]

in

How data analysis can pay off

Whenever Manchester United play at home, eight hours after kick-off the local crime rate jumps by almost 10 per cent – regardless of ... [more]

For how long will Japanese equities boom?

After two decades of disappointment Japanese equities posted an incredible 57 per cent return in 2013. Leading institutional investors met in Melbourne to ... [more]

Tackling lawyer led insurance claims

Some of the most influential people in the group insurance space met in Sydney in March to discuss the sustainability of the sector. ... [more]