Investment Magazine
 

Super and consumer experts debate the SG increase

  • 2 November, 2011
  • 0
  • print

The Federal Government’s plan to lift the Superannuation Guarantee (SG) from its current 9 per cent to 12 per cent unsurprisingly has widespread industry support. But it might be a surprise for some in the industry that the plan does not have universal and unequivocal community support.

The super debate begins

Legislation giving effect to the increase was introduced into Parliament today.

Opposition to the move predictably comes from the other side of politics. The Shadow Minister for Financial Services and Superannuation, Mathias Cormann, was involved in a Senate Estimates hearing on the day of a roundtable hosted by Investment Magazine and sponsored by Challenger, but the Opposition Leader’s chief of staff issued a statement.

It said: “As you know, the Coalition’s position is clear and we do not support the super increase funded from the mining tax.”

But reservations also have been expressed by those representing low-income-earners and workers with broken employment patterns (particularly women) – and out in the electorate, raising the SG is far from the sure-fire election winner some think it should be.

Eva Cox, the well-known feminist and convenor of the Women’s Equity Think Tank (WETT), is another opponent of the plan, but purely on equity grounds.

“Why don’t I support the increase? Because, I think the system itself is unfair because it puts an enormous amount of money into the pockets of the rich, and much less into the pockets of the less well off,” Cox says.

“I can’t see any reason why public money should be forgone on that sort of basis, and I think putting it up to 12 per cent is actually not going to do anything about the equity issues; it’s just going to make them worse.

“I’m a long-term feminist, and convenor of [the] Women’s Equity Think Tank, but at the moment I’m also attached to the Aboriginal Unit at UTS [University of Technology, Sydney], and I don’t think it’s going to do a damn thing for people in that area, either.”

The general philosophy behind increasing the SG is simple, says the Minister for Financial Services and Superannuation, Bill Shorten.

“There is little benefit in working for a long time and retiring poor,” he says.

Small business might be expected to oppose the plan too, but the chief executive of the Council of Small Business of Australia (COSBOA), Peter Strong, says the council frankly does not care if the SG is 9 per cent or 12 per cent or even 15 per cent; what COSBOA objects to is the administrative burden the SG already places on small business, which will not be alleviated.

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

© Copyright: Whole articles from this website and newsletter cannot be reproduced without permission from the editor. If you wish to publish introductions to any article please ensure that it links to original content site www.investmentmagazine.com.au, and that it shows clear attribution to Investment Magazine, plus author name and date. Failure to abide by this request will be considered a breach of copyright and legal action will be taken.

Vote
Is core property and global infrastructure heading for a price bubble?
 

Mercer to launch pooled self-annuitisation product

Mercer is to launch a group self-annuitisation product into the Australian market next week. The full details have not yet been disclosed, but ... [more]

in News

Future Fund co-invests to eke out extra return

The Future Fund is accelerating its program of co-investments as a means of improving its margin of return. Its investment team broadly agrees ... [more]

in News

AustralianSuper questions MySuper debate

AustralianSuper has broken a long silence on the MySuper debate by defending itself from criticism that it has not innovated. Alistair Barker, investment ... [more]

in News

Line-up of industry experts to choose best superannuation funds

Conexus Financial, the publisher of Investment Magazine and Professional Planner will again recognise outstanding achievement in superannuation when it hosts the third Superannuation Fund ... [more]

in News

Paul Sayer to become CEO of TWU Super

Paul Sayer is to leave his post as chief operating officer of REST Superannuation to become chief executive of TWU Super. Sayer will ... [more]

in News

Anne Whittaker to retire in December

Anne Whittaker, chief investment officer of Australian Catholic Super is to retire and will leave in December after more than six years at ... [more]

in News

Conservative options face grim five-year forecast

A scenario analysis tool developed by Frontier Advisors is confronting superannuation funds with the likelihood that their return objectives could be difficult to ... [more]

in News

Superpartners: The journey to Rhodes

“You really should visit our offices in Rhodes”. In a sector renowned for thinning profit margins and risky, expensive product development, the ebullience ... [more]

in News

Whitehelm Capital wins first advisory client in 8 years

Whitehelm Capital, formerly Access Capital Advisors, has reopened its advisory arm for targeted business after several years of being closed to new clients. ... [more]

in News

Three funds move into social impact investment space

The $31 billion QBE investment portfolio is to place $100m in social impact bonds in the belief that opportunities for such investments will ... [more]

in News

ACSI: Australian companies, probably the best governed in the world

The standard of governance among listed Australian companies leads the world, states the Australian Council of Superannuation Investors’ (ACSI), after it unveiled progress ... [more]

in News

Sunsuper seeks more smart partnerships with fund managers

Sunsuper is to expand on its success in partnering with distressed debt and private equity managers by seeking partnerships with listed equity managers ... [more]

in

Is our industry authentic about serving all members?

Many thought Alice Springs was an odd choice for last week’s AIST ASI conference. Perhaps the rationale was not explained well, but CEO ... [more]

in News

Product dashboards to reveal fund rankings

Super funds may soon have to display industry average fund performance and fees on their MySuper product dashboards. Speaking at the AIST ASI ... [more]

in News

QSuper spreads word on peer unaware benchmarks

QSuper used two sessions at the AIST ASI conference to explain its shift away from peer-benchmark investing, following its move to cohort strategies ... [more]

in News

Ken Marshman’s riposte to Grattan Institute report

An alternative set of proposals for reducing costs and boosting competition to those in the Grattan Institute Super Sting report, were presented by ... [more]

in News

Tasplan-Quadrant to lay down law to global equity managers

A combined $4 billion Tasplan and Quadrant Super is to reassess all global equity managers on their willingness to screen out tobacco stocks. ... [more]

Budget crisis? What crisis? Four investors give their views

Talk of an economic crisis has dominated the front pages of newspapers ever since Joe Hockey delivered his budget speech on May 13. ... [more]

in News

Numbers moving to SMSF stalls

David Atkin, chief executive of Cbus has declared the growth in members of industry funds leaving for self-managed super funds at an end. ... [more]

in News

Banks and industry funds unite against FSI proposals

“It is clear…. that the banking system is considerably less competitive than the superannuation system, is systemically more risky and extracts a greater ... [more]

in Opinion

The political shame in delaying rises in SGC for 7 years

There is a global pension underfunding crisis and yet Australians are set to lose $128 billion in savings because the Federal Government has ... [more]

in News

AMP Multi Asset Group structure finalised

AMP has finished the centralisation of its fund manager teams, creating four separate chief investment officer roles under the leadership of Sean Henaghan. ... [more]

in News

Future Fund creates twin leadership roles

The Future Fund has promoted internally to fill its chief investment officer role, while passing the responsibility for portfolio risk setting to another ... [more]

in News

RiceWarner: beating annuities “easy” for super funds

Superannuation funds can offer retirement accounts that easily exceed the income from annuities, believes Rice Warner. Michael Rice, chief executive of the actuarial ... [more]

AustralianSuper claims growing influence on ASX200 governance

Superannuation funds are winning their efforts to make Australian companies adopt long term thinking, according to Andrew Gray, investment manager, governance at AustralianSuper. ... [more]

in News

David Murray profile: superannuation put on trial

How worried should the superannuation industry be by the contents of the Financial System Inquiry’s interim report? The comments made by David Murray ... [more]

in News

REST credits insurance rethink as they scoop top fund award

REST Super scooped Super Fund of the Year, in large part due to pioneering a new insurance offering for members said Damian Hill. ... [more]

in News

QSuper wins pension fund of the year

QSuper has been chosen as Pension Fund of the Year for the second year running at the Chant West | Conexus Finanical Super ... [more]

Super fund award winners named

The winners of the Chant West | Conexus Financial Super Fund Awards have been announced at a ceremony at Ivy Ballroom in Sydney, ... [more]

in News

Peter Baker to lead Mercer’s custodian and manager due diligence team

Mercer has appointed Peter Baker, formerly managing director of BNP Paribas Securities and Services in Australia, as the head of its Sentinel team ... [more]

in News

Retail fund directors scrutinised over commissions

The revelation that as much as seven per cent of money in APRA-approved default funds will pay out commissions to advisers until 2017 ... [more]

in

Profile: Michael Strachan, CIO, Equip

Michael Stachan, chief investment officer, Equipsuper refers to his team as investment managers and risk managers, whose job is to preserve its $6.5 ... [more]

in News

Australia moves to second place on global pension index

The ranking of Australia’s superannuation system has moved from third to second best system in the world largely due to the recent increase ... [more]